• Home
  • Work With Me
    • Online Better Body Coaching
    • SHIFT40
    • 1:1 Coaching
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Shop My Favourites
  • Nav Social Icons

  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Work With Me
    • Online Better Body Coaching
    • SHIFT40
    • 1:1 Coaching
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Shop My Favourites
  • Mobile Menu Widgets

    Connect

    Search

Health - Mindset - Life

Why 19 Out Of 20 Dieters Will Fail

August 15, 2022 · In: Mindset, Nutrition Tips


Why Most Diets Fail, And What You Can Do About It

Image made on Canva Pro

The sad truth is that most people who set out on a weight loss diet will fail. But why do most diets fail?

Not only do they fail, but 60% of those dieters will actually to gain more weight than when they started due to screwing up their metabolism in the process.

Women will try over 130 diets in their lifetime, averaging about 2 a year that lasts just 30 days each.

So what can you do differently to try and make sure you get into the top 5% of dieters that actually succeed and be able to keep it up without giving up your entire life in the process?

1. Going In Too Hard

When getting started with any diet, it’s all very well to go in all guns blazing. Motivation is high and the promise from the marketing material says that this is going to be the diet that finally works for you.

The truth is that many diets are too restrictive, they cut calories down too low, too quickly, cut out major food groups or have too many banned foods.

Combine this with intense exercise on a schedule that is way more than you really have time for and it becomes incredibly unsustainable, not to mention painful and stressful. This conjures up a pretty miserable experience, that most people with busy lives just can’t keep on going with.

Do this instead — When starting any diet ask yourself if you could see yourself eating this way in a year’s time. Could you keep on exercising this way forever? If not, maybe give that diet a wide birth.

Start small and be patient.

2. For The Love Of Food

Loving food too much is a common excuse that I think most of us have uttered at some point in our dieting experiences. Believing that you have to give up all the foods that you love puts a lot of emphasis on your willpower.

Most of us suck when it comes to willpower, and so relying on willpower alone is a sure route to failure.

Do this instead — Remind yourself that no foods are barred, you don’t have to cut out entire food groups. You can eat the foods you love, when they are balanced out with foods that will support your goals.

Learn to make healthy meals that also taste good too, without having to obsess over rules and restrictions. Learn what a balanced diet means to you and fill up on the good stuff so your body isn’t constantly starving and craving missing nutrients. Enjoy the foods that you love, just don’t be a dick about it when you are eating them.

3. Giving Up Your Social Life

The above-mentioned rules and restrictions can make having a social life extremely hard. Sure I believe there will be times we can say no to a night out or event in the name of self-care. I’m a natural introvert and space and time alone are essential for me.

But continually avoiding going out so that you can stick with your diet is pretty disordered behaviour. Life is way more than being on a diet and giving up precious time with the people that you love.

Do this instead — Allow yourself the freedom to do the things you love. That will sometimes include food and drink. Yet nothing is barred you can approach it with the mentality of knowing you don’t need to binge or gorge to enjoy.

Be mindful about what you are consuming and check in with yourself regularly and ask yourself how you feel. You soon come to realise that eating the junk you thought you wanted doesn’t actually feel that good.

4. The Stress Factor

Stress is a major component of dieting success. Think about all of the times you have fallen off your diet before. Chances are it was an emotional response to a seemingly stressful thought or experience. Am I right?

Yet we live in a time when stress is at an all time high. We are constantly switched on and downtime is lacking. If you want to feel more balanced with your eating behaviours and managage emotional triggers, work on reducing your stress levels.

Do this instead — Explore stress management tools and implement the ones that are most effective for you into part of your self-care routine. The less stressed you are, the easier it is to stay in alignment with your diet and fitness intentions.

For me personally, the best ways to manage stress are by prioritising sleep, journaling, walks in nature and meditation. Find what works for you.Why You Need To Prioritise This First If You Want To Lose Weight
The Key to a Happier Healthier Youmedium.com

5. Dieter Individuality

Most diet programmes are cookie cutter programmes. Meaning that everyone gets the same bulk of information. And I’ll be honest I run a group fitness and nutrition programme and there has to be some standardising in the practices unless you want one-to-one coaching.

A lot of base practices will apply to most people. But I’m also very careful to impress throughout the entire experience, that health and nutrition is never a one size fits all approach, it’s infinatly varied from one person to another.

There has to be flexibility and individuality as what works for one person, maybe a complete disaster for another. We all differ in physiology, psychology, personal preferences as well as lifestyle/time availability.

Do this instead — Approach any diet as an experiment, learn to monitor how your body responds to different foods and styles of eating. If what you are doing helps you manage your hunger, energy and cravings as well as helps you to maintain your optimum physique, then keep doing that. If not, then it’s time to try a different approach.

6. Not Seeing Results Quick Enough

You think that by following the plan for 7 days you are going to look like the Instagram influencer who sold it to you. Yet the truth is, that fitness influencer has trained for years to look that way and it’s likely their full-time job. This doesn’t even mention some of the questionable behaviours they may be practising that they don’t tell you about, and a lot of the time they are not following the programme as is being sold to you.

Results take time. And even if you eat the way you are told, and workout the way you are told, you probably still won’t ever look like them due to your individual genetic factors. Many people have unrealistic expectations and then this crushes motivation when the results don’t roll in fast enough.

Do this instead — Take your time, be patient, keep consistent but also be kind with yourself too. Look at it as a long-term change in your lifestyle. As cliche as that sounds, it’s true, you are in for the long haul and need to stop searching for the quick fix, it doesn’t exist.


Most of these factors address the mindset element of your wellness and weight loss journey, all of this is important before you even start digging into the strategy of weight loss.

We get way too hung up on the weight loss goal, but I feel it’s far more important to approach a health journey regardless of the weight.

There is far too much emphasis on the number on the scale and we need to drop that pressure and focus on the bigger picture of health. To eat better, move better and ultimately live a happier life.

When that focus shifts, then your success will shift too.


If you are looking for true transformation join the 28 Online Better Body Coaching programme and get personalised support in reaching your health goals. CLICK HERE to find out more.

By: admin · In: Mindset, Nutrition Tips · Tagged: weight loss tips, why do most diets fail

you’ll also love

happy mammoth weight lossHappy Mammoth Weight Loss Protocol Review: Real Results After 90 Days
how many calories should I eat to lose weight calculatorHow to Use AI (ChatGPT) to Calculate Calories, Macros & Create Meal Plans for Fat Loss
15 Steps to Lose 15lbs as a Woman Over 40 (Without Dieting Like It’s 1999)

Join the List

Get access to the free 5-day Better Body kickstart plan

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Next Post >

How To Know If You Are Drinking Enough Water

Primary Sidebar

Meet Emma

Meet Emma
hello!

Hey, I'm Emma. I help 40+ women eat better, move better and live happier. Start your Better Body journey today by joining the 5 day kickstart challenge!

Join Now

Connect

Coaching With Emma

Featured Posts

Mounjaro Weight Loss Journey | Before & After Month 1 Results

Marks & Spencer Goodmove Activewear Review | Spring 2026

Why I’m Starting a GLP-1 Weight Loss Medication (Mounjaro) as a Health & Fitness Coach

Categories

  • Fitness
  • Lifestyle
  • Nutrition

Search

Archives

Follow Along

@emmacolseynicholls

emmacolseynicholls

You have to keep going. You deserve to see what ha You have to keep going. You deserve to see what happens when all you hard work pays off

This week has tired me out. Lots on and a few rubbish night sleep has thrown me. But still we go, good things and happening and more to come

Keep going 🙌🙌

#fitness #fitnessmotivation #fitnessover40 #weightlossjourney
Midlife women… is M&S activewear actually worth Midlife women… is M&S activewear actually worth it? @marksandspencer 

I tested a full haul to find out — from budget leggings to jackets — and some of the results genuinely surprised me.

I’m on a mission to find the best workout clothes for women 40+, so you don’t have to waste your money.

For the full post with links comment 'LINKS' or send me a DM and I'll send it over

#WomenOver40 #MSGoodmove #ActivewearReview #MidlifeStyle #FitnessOver40
When u get mountain fomo, u have to force ya self When u get mountain fomo, u have to force ya self out even when tired. Perfect couple hours up at @rocdenfer_officiel 

Thanks for always being the yes woman @mildlyyellow 🙌🙌
Fitness is for life, not just for the summer body Fitness is for life, not just for the summer body goals

So find the joy and appreciation in moving your body. 

O now look at movement as the greatest form of self care and much needed head space in a busy world

#fitness #fitnessmotivaton #fitnessover40
Dreams and goals don’t happen by accident. They Dreams and goals don’t happen by accident. They happen by action!!

Whatever goal you have in your mind, write it down, break it down then today take one action step forward

Step into the uncomfortable 

#goals #goalsettingtips #motivation
My favourite compression leggings for heavy liftin My favourite compression leggings for heavy lifting days. They have the most insane tummy control and also super supportive back band too

They just help me to feel fully supported when I really want to push my heavy lift days. 

These are the Powerband Resistance Leggings from @fankaofficial 

#workoutfits #workoutclothes #gymleggings #fanka #ad
The right time to start making changes to your hea The right time to start making changes to your health and fitness habits does not exist

You are never going to magically start having more time

You just have to get started. Do it when it’s imperfect, start when it’s messy, start when it’s inconvenient

That’s when it will really start to stick

#fitness #fitnessmotivaton #fitnessover40
Starting my weight loss journey on a GLP1 medicati Starting my weight loss journey on a GLP1 medication mounjaro. It’s not been an easy decision to start this and also to share this. As a health coach there are feelings of failure and fear of judgement. But with my challenges with PCOS and insulin resistance I just couldn’t get the weight to come off and was currently sitting at an unhealthy body fat percentage. 

So I’m sharing my journey on using this as a tool to improve my health and regain and healthy body weight and hopefully o prove my PCos symptoms in the prices

2 weeks in I’m 7lb down. Slow and steady is the goal while also maintaining as much muscle as I can. 

#glp1journey #mounjaro
Over 40? The basics matter more than ever. Before Over 40? The basics matter more than ever.

Before you chase the next plan, ask yourself:
✔ Am I sleeping enough? 7-9 hours?
✔ Am I eating enough protein? 30-40g at my main meals
✔ Am I moving daily? 7k + steps
✔ Am I managing stress?

Get these right first. Everything else becomes easier.

Save this for you year long reminder
#midlifehealth #fitnessover40 #simplehealth #newyearfocus
Sometimes your best with be showing up and hitting Sometimes your best with be showing up and hitting a new PB. Other days it’s just getting up and going through the motions. 

Progress is never linear. It’s the never giving up on yourself that matters

#fitnessmotivaton #fitnessinspiration #fitnessover40
Just do your best Just do your best
One of the biggest mistakes I see women 40+ making One of the biggest mistakes I see women 40+ making in the gym is not training with enough intensity.

As Stacy Sims teaches, those last few reps of your sets should feel hard — that struggle is the signal your body needs to:
✔️ hold onto muscle
✔️ support metabolism
✔️ protect bone density
✔️ stay strong as hormones change

This is exactly why I’ve loved the Power Happens programme so much. It’s pushed me to lift heavier, train with purpose, and honestly… I feel stronger now than I have in years 💪

If you want the link to my full review + the programme, comment “Sims” and I’ll send it to you.

#StacySims #PowerTrainingForWomen #WomenOver40Fitness #MidlifeStrength #TrainWithIntent
Iv always been a fan of @leangreens but it’s got Iv always been a fan of @leangreens but it’s got even better as their new blend also contains collagen and creatine 👌. 

Both of which are important especially for us midlife women. And you are getting all the good stuff into one scoop

I add mine into my morning smoothie to make sure I’m topped up with the good stuff for the day

#leangreens #midlifesupport #bestsupplements
Start now, start messy, start when it’s inconven Start now, start messy, start when it’s inconvenient 

Because sometimes ‘I’ll do it later’ turns into never getting it done

#fitnessmotivaton #fitnessover40
We got a snow day so we went to play ❤️ We got a snow day so we went to play ❤️
What’s the best fat burning exercise? Something What’s the best fat burning exercise? Something I get asked a lot. And really there isn’t one, some may even say running but here is why strength training should be a priority as a woman over 40 if you are in a mission to lose body fat 👇👇

Muscle is what keeps your metabolic engine healthy. And as we age we start to lose it. Meaning your goal should be at the very least to maintain the muscle you have. 

Not only will it help you maintain your curves and prevent you looking flat and saggy as you lose body fat

But strength training will help you maintain strength, functionality, maintain your youth, avoid injury, keep your metabolism stoked and keeps you out if the nursing home. 

Strength training is for longevity as much as it is asthetics. 

Your old lady body will thank you for it. 

Want to look and feel better in 2026??
💪 2-3 full body strength sessions a week
💪 1 x HIIT or SIT training session 
💪 Daily movement 7-10k steps a day

#howtolosefat #fitnesstips #fitnessover40
It’s also where most of the growth happens #fit It’s also where most of the growth happens

#fitnessmotivation #fitnessover40
Determined to stick with your diet & fitness goals Determined to stick with your diet & fitness goals this year? You’re not alone! January motivation feels great — until life gets in the way. But consistency (not perfection!) is where the magic happens. 

Here are 7 shifts that will help you make your goals actually stick (no crash diets or burnout required). Here’s the gist👇 👇

1. Set Clear & Realistic Goals
Skip vague resolutions like “eat healthier” or “get fit”. Set specific, measurable habits — like “walk 20 mins daily” or “add veg to every meal”. When it’s clear, it’s achievable. 

2. Plan, Schedule & Notice Where You Are
Structure helps consistency thrive! Block out workouts & meals in your calendar — treat them like important appointments. 

3. Build Habits Slowly
Trying to do it all at once is overwhelming and unsustainable. Pick one or two small habits, make them automatic, then add the next. Tiny changes = big results over time. 

4. Find Your Support System
Accountability makes sticking with goals easier — friends, family, coaches, or a community who gets it. Movement feels better when you’re not doing it alone! 

5. Track Your Progress
Track more than weight. Journals, mood, strength gains, consistency streaks — these wins keep you motivated when the scale doesn’t budge. 

6. Start Even When It’s Messy
f you wait for perfect timing… you might never start! Progress isn’t tidy — start in the chaos and keep moving forward anyway. 

7. Treat Health as Self-Care
Health isn’t just aesthetic — it’s self-care. When you shift your mindset from “dieting” to “nourishing”, caring for yourself becomes something you want to do, not something you have to do. 

Remember: Life happens — but small consistent steps still add up. You don’t have to be perfect — you just have to show up again tomorrow. 

Tell me: What’s one habit you’re focusing on this week? 👇

Want support to make those habits stick? I’m here for you ❤️ 

#FitnessOver40 #HealthyHabits #MindsetShift #ConsistencyWins
Have you set your New Year goals and intentions ye Have you set your New Year goals and intentions yet??

 #goals #goalsetting
It’s easy to forget all that you have experience It’s easy to forget all that you have experienced and all that you have achieved if you don’t take the time to look back and reflect

This year could have felt like a little bit of a nothing year but as a family we have been deep in the grind but I also get to appreciate that we still had a wonderful year that I’m so deeply grateful for. 

Reaching 10k subs on YouTube, my first major brand deal, coming back to pole, first hyrox, my kids getting sponsored by a snowboard brand and Clayton getting into team GB next generation squad. Getting to work with some wonderful clients. 

It’s been a challenging year but with it has come a lot of growth and I’m excited to keep going and keep growing in 2026

Wishing you all a wonderful new year 🙌
Follow on Instagram

Footer

Shop

Info

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Website Terms Of Use

stay in the know

Copyright © 2026 · Theme by 17th Avenue

Manage Cookie Consent
We use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. We do this to improve browsing experience and to show personalized ads. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}